Set six pale tiles on a worktable and the gaps look like black lines. Put a light grout between them and the same layout can read as a single surface. If you choose a joint colour while the tile is still loose, you’re imagining a surprisingly large part of the finished wall.

Build a fair comparison

Ask the installer for two small sample panels using tiles from your actual batch. Give them the same layout and the joint width proposed for the job. Choose two grout shades that are close enough to be plausible alternatives. Let each sample cure as directed before comparing it with a printed chart or a photograph.

Read the edges

A shade close to the tile softens the outline of each piece. A stronger contrast draws attention to the grid and to small variations in handmade edges. Hold the panels vertically for a splashback. Move them under the cabinet light, then look again from the doorway. The panel you enjoy examining up close might be the one you find too busy from the table.

Keep the decision specific

Once you choose, note the tile batch, grout colour and product, proposed joint width and panel orientation. Ask the installer how corners and changes of plane will be detailed separately. Keeping a sample board until the work is finished gives both of you a shared reference when a section of fresh work looks different under site lighting.

MAPEI recommends testing a grout on a representative sample before applying it across the whole tiled surface. [1]